WENESDAY, FEBUARY 28 1872 that knew them then, knew them, "no more for ever" - I remember - something broke up the discussion before it came to its natural conclusion, and neither party was exactley satisfied. A newspaper controversy was the result - in which stronger language was used than was either seemly or charitable - Daniel McIntosh the little knock-kneed schoolmaster of Woodside (a Baptist of the old school) taking a leading part - however the Churchmen proud of their young champion who in the language of their opponents had got "his hands clear of the trade" determined on a Testimonial - And I have no doubt that Dr Wright of Southampton, whatever may now be his opinions of the merits of the controversy, looks back with the highest pleasure, on that summer evening, when his old School fellows, and companions at the loom, met and under the guidance of James Strachan, presented him with a handsome "Silver Watch & Chain" both as a mark of esteem for the individual and also as an appreciation of the "fearless exponent" of the cause which they held so dear - But dark days were now lowering over the "Porter Lodge of Keithock". John had gone to college for the Winter Session our "Mother" took ill after harvest - and was bedfast - during the Winter he made one hasty visit during her illness and the next was to her funeral in March 1860, though remembering distinctly enough all the events as they happened there is a want of unity for a year at this time that I cannot account for - Brother William went to learn shoemaking - May & I & Baby Jim were left to keep house - Father ever at work from six to six. John paid us short visits - but I began to feel "He no longer